This week, US Magistrate Judge Richard Lloret directed Boehringer Ingelheim to disclose its launch plans for its biosimilar adalimumab, Cyltezo, as part of a long-running patent dispute with AbbVie, maker of the reference adalimumab, Humira.
This week, US Magistrate Judge Richard Lloret directed Boehringer Ingelheim (BI) to disclose its launch plans for its biosimilar adalimumab, Cyltezo, as part of a long-running patent dispute with AbbVie, maker of the reference adalimumab, Humira.
AbbVie filed a request to compel BI to detail its launch plans, saying that the plans are relevant to BI’s “unclean hands” defense, a legal defense that bars a party who is asking for a judgment from receiving the court’s help if that party has behaved unethically with respect to the subject of the lawsuit. According to BI, AbbVie’s strategy of acquiring what BI describes as overlapping, noninventive patents to hinder biosimilar competition could constitute unclean hands on AbbVie’s part.
According to AbbVie, BI’s public statements that it intends to launch Cyltezo prior to Humira’s patent expiry contradict BI’s claim that AbbVie’s patent estate has blocked BI from bringing its drug to the US market.
AbbVie also claims that BI is stockpiling Cyltezo ahead of a launch, an action that AbbVie says would infringe its patents.
BI, however, argues that the Biologics Price Competition and Innovation Act (BPCIA)’s provision of a 180-day notice of commercial marketing would be disrupted if the company were compelled to make its launch plans known to AbbVie.
Judge Lloret wrote in his memorandum that the BPCIA does not prevent or limit discovery in a biosimilar litigation, and that “Boehringer reads too much into the statute…the 180-day notice requirement is not designed to cloak launch plans with a broad ranging privilege against disclosure before the notice is filed.”
The judge also wrote that BI’s account of the motive behind and the consequences of AbbVie’s alleged misconduct related a patent thicket is central to its argument. The degree to which Humira’s patents delayed BI’s launch of its biosimilar “may have a legitimate impact on a fact-finder’s assessment of whether AbbVie has unclean hands,” he wrote. If BI argues that a patent thicket was created in order to delay competition and harm competitors, then it “would be unfair” for BI to refuse to quantify the damage caused.
Judge Lloret wrote that he will allow limited discovery and would require BI to state whether it contends that an alleged patent thicket delayed its launch plans for Cyltezo; if BI says that its plans were not delayed, “that will be an end to the discovery dispute.”
With respect to AbbVie’s concerns about BI’s alleged stockpiling of Cyltezo, however, the judge wrote that discovery would have minimal value and would pose a disproportionate burden, and he denied AbbVie’s request.
This latest development comes just weeks after Judge Lloret directed AbbVie to turn over to BI its documents related to its efforts to obtain patents on Humira. The judge agreed with BI that AbbVie had failed to produce numerous documents related to its patenting program and ordered AbbVie to “engage in rapid and punctilious compliance” with the order to produce the relevant materials.
Biosimilars Policy Roundup for April 2024—Podcast Edition
May 5th 2024On this episode of Not So Different, The Center for Biosimilars® glances back at all the major biosimilar policy updates from April, including 2 FDA approvals, 1 European approval, and several insights into possible policy changes from the Festival of Biologics USA conference.
Exploring the Biosimilar Horizon: Julie Reed's Predictions for 2024
February 18th 2024On this episode of Not So Different, Julie Reed, executive director of the Biosimilars Forum, returns to discuss her predictions for the biosimilar industry for 2024 and beyond as well as the impact that the Forum's 4 new members will have on the organization's mission.
Dr Sophia Humphreys Provides Calls to Action to Ensure Biosimilar Market Sustainability
April 30th 2024During her presentation during Festival of Biologics USA, Sophia Humphreys, PharmD, director of formulary management at Sutter Health, gave an overview of current challenges and opportunities for the biosimilar market and offered calls to action for multiple stakeholders.
Eye on Pharma: EU Ustekinumab Approval; New Golimumab Data; Evernorth Adds Humira Biosimilar
April 29th 2024The European Union gained a new ustekinumab biosimilar; Alvotech released positive results from a clinical trial evaluating a golimumab biosimilar and the reference products (Simponi and Simponi Aria), and Evernorth announced that it is set to cover an adalimumab biosimilar at zero cost to patients.