The US Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) has decided that the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe cannot claim sovereign immunity from inter partes review (IPR) of Allergan’s patents covering Restasis, and that the IPR proceedings on those patents can continue with Allergan as the patent owner.
The US Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) has decided that the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe cannot claim sovereign immunity from inter partes review (IPR) of Allergan’s patents covering Restasis, and that the IPR proceedings on those patents can continue with Allergan as the patent owner.
The decision stems from Allergan’s 2017 transfer of patents covering its dry-eye drug to the Tribe in exchange for invoking sovereign immunity from IPRs. The move came less than 1 week before a scheduled oral hearing for several instituted IPRs of patents covering Restasis. The Tribe then moved to dismiss the scheduled proceedings for lack of jurisdiction.
After considering numerous amicus briefs (and the supplemental briefs of both the petitioners and the patent owners), the PTAB determined that “…the Tribe has not established that the doctrine of tribal sovereign immunity should be applied to these proceedings. Furthermore, we determine that these proceedings can continue even without the Tribe’s participation in view of Allergan’s retained ownership interests in the challenged patents.”
Among the reasons for its decision, says the PTAB, is that tribal sovereignty is subject to the superior control of Congress, and that acts of Congress apply to tribes. Thus, since Congress has enacted a statute that stipulates that any patent is subject to the requirements of law, including IPRs, tribal ownership of a patent does not shield the owner from an IPR proceeding.
Furthermore, the PTAB agreed with the petitioners in their claim that Allergan is the true owner of the patents in question, regardless of how Allergan and the Tribe characterized their arrangement. The PTAB addresses the following among its reasons for the decision:
However, the PTAB did not address the question of whether the arrangement between the Tribe and Allergan was proper; in October 2017, Judge William C. Bryson, who presided over an unrelated Hatch-Waxman litigation concerning Restasis, called for briefs addressing “…whether the assignment of the patents to the Tribe should be disregarded as a sham.” Bryson later invalidated the patents in question in this case.
In its decision, the PTAB wrote that, “In reaching this conclusion, we do not comment on whether the License and the other agreements between the Tribe and Allergan constitute a ‘sham’ transaction, nor do we need to decide whether the agreements are otherwise improper under the law.”
Budget Impact Analysis of Biosimilar Natalizumab in the US
Projected savings from biosimilar natalizumab were $452,611 over 3 years, driven by decreased drug acquisition costs and a utilization shift from reference to biosimilar natalizumab.
Biosimilars in America: Overcoming Barriers and Maximizing Impact
July 21st 2024Join us as we explore the complexities of the US biosimilars market, discussing legislative influences, payer and provider adoption factors, and strategies to overcome industry challenges with expert insights from Kyle Noonan, PharmD, MS, value & access strategy manager at Cencora.
Biosimilars Policy Roundup for April 2024—Podcast Edition
May 5th 2024On this episode of Not So Different, The Center for Biosimilars® glances back at all the major biosimilar policy updates from April, including 2 FDA approvals, 1 European approval, and several insights into possible policy changes from the Festival of Biologics USA conference.
Hesitancy in MENA Nations to Adopt WHO Biosimilar Guidelines Hinders Market Development
July 17th 2024The World Health Organization’s (WHO) new guidelines for biosimilar approvals aim to save time and money for manufacturers in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA), but hesitancy among nations to adopt the guidelines is stifling market development of biosimilars.
BioRationality: Time to Get Rid of PBMs if Biosimilars Are to Succeed
July 15th 2024Sarfaraz K. Niazi, PhD, discusses the challenges with pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) that plague the biosimilar industry and new legislation that attempts to reform their practices and encourage biosimilar adoption.