This month, US magistrate judge Richard A. Lloret granted Boehringer Ingelheim (BI)’s motion to compel AbbVie to produce prelitigation disclosures and settlements concerning its brand-name adalimumab, Humira.
This month, US magistrate judge Richard A. Lloret granted Boehringer Ingelheim (BI)’s motion to compel AbbVie to produce prelitigation disclosures as well as settlements concerning its brand-name adalimumab, Humira.
BI is engaged in a lawsuit with AbbVie over biosimilar adalimumab, Cyltezo, and the biosimilar developer had requested that the court require AbbVie to produce relevant information from another such litigation, concerning Amgen’s Amgevita, as well as from settlement agreements that AbbVie entered into with Amgen, Samsung Bioepis, and Mylan regarding their biosimilar adalimumab products.
Judge Lloret found that the disclosures concerning the litigation with Amgen are relevant to the case and can be provided by AbbVie with minimal burden, as long as reasonable confidentiality procedures are followed. He also found that the disclosures related to settlements are likely to be relevant to BI’s defenses of patent invalidity and unenforceability and that, given adequate confidentiality provisions, producing settlement documents does not pose an undue burden for AbbVie.
Separately, Judge Lloret denied AbbVie’s motion to require that BI provide more complete responses to 2 of its questions, one related to BI’s safe harbor defense and the other related to the time at which BI learned about patents that are at issue in the suit.
In the first instance, found Judge Lloret, the probative value of the information sought by AbbVie is “remote” and unlikely to be material to the resolution of the case’s issues. In the second, he found that the burden imposed by the discovery is disproportionate to whatever value it may have to the resolution of the case.
These new developments follow Judge Lloret’s February 2019 order to BI to divulge its launch plans for Cyltezo as part of the patent dispute. According to a memorandum, BI’s plans, and the degree to which AbbVie’s alleged patent thicket for Humira may have delayed those launch plans, may have a legitimate impact on BI’s unclean hands defense: a legal defense that bars a party who is asking for a judgment from receiving the court’s help if that party has behaved unethically with respect to the subject of the lawsuit.
According to BI, AbbVie’s strategy of acquiring what BI describes as overlapping, noninventive patents to hinder biosimilar competition could constitute unclean hands on AbbVie’s part.
Also in February, Judge Lloret ordered AbbVie to turn over 14 different categories of documents, including those related to its patenting program and its efforts directed toward mitigating the impact of biosimilar competition on its business.
Budget Impact Analysis of Biosimilar Natalizumab in the US
Projected savings from biosimilar natalizumab were $452,611 over 3 years, driven by decreased drug acquisition costs and a utilization shift from reference to biosimilar natalizumab.
Biosimilars in America: Overcoming Barriers and Maximizing Impact
July 21st 2024Join us as we explore the complexities of the US biosimilars market, discussing legislative influences, payer and provider adoption factors, and strategies to overcome industry challenges with expert insights from Kyle Noonan, PharmD, MS, value & access strategy manager at Cencora.
Biosimilars Policy Roundup for April 2024—Podcast Edition
May 5th 2024On this episode of Not So Different, The Center for Biosimilars® glances back at all the major biosimilar policy updates from April, including 2 FDA approvals, 1 European approval, and several insights into possible policy changes from the Festival of Biologics USA conference.
Hesitancy in MENA Nations to Adopt WHO Biosimilar Guidelines Hinders Market Development
July 17th 2024The World Health Organization’s (WHO) new guidelines for biosimilar approvals aim to save time and money for manufacturers in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA), but hesitancy among nations to adopt the guidelines is stifling market development of biosimilars.
BioRationality: Time to Get Rid of PBMs if Biosimilars Are to Succeed
July 15th 2024Sarfaraz K. Niazi, PhD, discusses the challenges with pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) that plague the biosimilar industry and new legislation that attempts to reform their practices and encourage biosimilar adoption.